By Adel AlAdlani*

While Washington celebrates and mourns the shifting tides of power, a quieter reality settles over city halls across Michigan. Across the state, 125 local water projects requested more than $1 billion in help this year, only to walk away with less than three cents on the dollar. The need behind those requests is not abstract. Michigan still carries 202,178 lead service lines across 227 community water systems, the fourth highest count in the nation, with 80,595 of them in Detroit alone. In Southwest Detroit, a planned glass factory had its $31.7 million federal grant canceled last fall and renegotiated nearly a year later, pushing production back into 2027. When Washington lurches from one political swing to the next, roads still need paving and aging pipes still need replacing. Local leaders do not have the luxury of partisan theater. They are simply left holding the bag.

At the heart of this crisis is governing by convulsion. Public works take years, not two-year election cycles. You cannot pave roads, upgrade transit, or replace lead pipes on frozen promises. Consider what happened to Michigan schools last summer. The U.S. Department of Education withheld roughly $157 million while conducting a review, leaving local districts guessing at their budgets just weeks before the opening bell. The money eventually arrived, yet the damage was already done in chaos, delay, and wasted hours.

Shrinking federal capacity and unfunded mandates only deepen the strain. Even as Washington asks more of local communities, federal staff cuts mean slower grant approvals and fewer experts on the other end of the phone. A University of Michigan survey found that 60 percent of local governments in the state were not preparing for a drop in federal or state funding. It was not for lack of worry. Most simply lack the staff to plan for constant uncertainty. Large cities have dedicated grant writing teams. Small townships in the Upper Peninsula and mid Michigan do not. In Watersmeet Township, the supervisor keeps a 25-page state grant agreement on her desk for $100,000 in new water meters, complete with monthly financial reports and quarterly progress updates. For small townships without large administrative teams, she explained, that kind of paperwork often keeps communities from applying for grants at all. One Upper Peninsula community still runs a snowplow built in the 1970s. Another figures it receives enough money to replace its roads once every 80 years, though a road lasts about 30.

Still, local government holds a quiet advantage. Municipal leaders are judged by the things people see and touch every day, such as clean water, cleared snow, and how fast an ambulance arrives. Ideology does not fill a water main. Across Michigan, local officials prove what is possible when given half a chance. Through the federal Get the Lead Out initiative, communities from Muskegon Heights and Dowagiac to Three Rivers, Ferndale, and Ypsilanti mapped old pipes, built replacement plans, and brought residents into the work through door knocking, surveys, and community meetings. When federal, state, and local leaders pull in the same direction, public service works. But the work is a fraction of what is needed. Michigan has replaced 98,253 lead and galvanized lines since 2021, a real achievement, yet the state’s full water infrastructure gap runs to $2.8 billion a year, and communities have historically spent about $1.14 billion.

Even the strongest communities, however, have a breaking point. Local property taxes and user fees cannot forever patch the holes left by an unpredictable Washington. Congress and the White House must trade volatile, micromanaged grants for steady, multi-year funding that survives the swing of elections. State leaders, in turn, should give cities room to breathe and stop handing down mandates without the money to pay for them. Democracy works best when the people closest to a problem have the tools to fix it. Washington does not need to run America’s cities. It just needs to keep its word.

_______________________________________________________________________

* Adel AlAdlani has a PhD in Public Administration from Western Michigan University